It has not been surprising how over the past few days, every
news channel is going berserk with debates, discussions, news-specials and
breaking-news about the ‘India Against Corruption’ campaign which has been
going on for quite some time now. There have been views both for and against
the movement, some subdued, others harsh. But there are a few points which made
me ponder upon what exactly was and is happening.
Firstly, as I hear each social-activist, celebrity,
politician and even common people exclaim on the television how every Indian is
sick and tired of corruption in the country. I wonder if every Indian citizen
is against corruption, then who exactly are the corrupt people ? Are they some
individuals imported from places like North Korea,
Iraq or Kazakhstan ?
I know my question appears rather stupid, as ‘every Indian’
here means every citizen who is not corrupt. Then who exactly is corrupt ?
And then I come to realize that the common man or the ‘aam
aadmi’ of India
refers to the government officials, bureaucrats and politicians when he talks about corruption. So I ask, are
theses people then, some foreign nationals who have smuggled into India
for the purpose of looting its people ? Or is it the Chinese population who
voted for our parliamentarians ???
NO ! All the
corrupt people against whom all of India
is fighting are legal citizens of India as well. But are these
government-related individuals any different from the rest of the Indian
population ? (except the fact that they are corrupt)
NO ! They come
from the very society that makes up the rest of the population. Be it a peon, a
clerk, a bureaucrat, a politician or a minister. And it is certain that a
person’s economic class has nothing to do with him being corrupt or not. A
peon, if corrupt, will ask for a bribe, just as a minister will, to help a
business lobby.
And there’s a war
going on between the IAC movement and the government about passing a bill. The
IAC wants a ‘Jan Lokpal Bill’ while the government is adamant on its own
version of a ‘Lokpal Bill’. And it is almost an accepted perception that such a
bill will certainly curtail corruption and without which corruption cannot be
checked. As if such a Bill/law/anti-corruption body is the one and only way to
weed out corruption from the country.
So, in other
words, we are trying to emphasize that we, the corrupt people, will not change
unless and until there is a law which honestly and efficiently checks us if we
are corrupt and punishes us if we are guilty !
Isn’t it amazing
how we dance, sing, fly the tricolor and rejoice in anticipation of the passing
of such a ‘Bill’. Isn’t it like rejoicing about the realization of the extent
of corruption ?
Should we
actually be proud that our society has come to such a low that there is no hope
of us changing and we simply refuse to change unless we are checked and
punished ??? That we will stop being corrupt only when forced by the law…
It is said that
corruption is so rampant because the people in charge are not accountable. And
that the people at the helm are corrupt themselves so corruption is rooted deep
into the system. Doesn’t that mean that every subordinate will continue to be
corrupt till his superior is corrupt too ?
Are all
government officials honest people before they join their jobs ?
Do they become
corrupt only after they get into the government service ?
If they were
honest before, should they become corrupt just because they have a corrupt
superior who doesn’t check them ?
Each and every
government official and employee is from amongst us. They may be someone from
our family, friends, neighbors or relatives. Then how do they manage to become
corrupt ? Is a person corrupt without his family knowing about it ? But still,
we as a society let it happen just because it is someone close to us. And we
point fingers to those whom we are not related to.
Secondly, is
corruption only synonymous with the government ? Is every other individual in
any other field of work completely honest ?
What about the
doctor at a private hospital who refers his patients for useless investigations
just because he gets a part of the investigation charges too ? Is that not
corruption ? (Being from the medical field I have witnessed things which might
put even a government employee to shame)
What about the
employee of a Multi National company who prepares forged bills for
re-imbursement from his company ? Is he not corrupt ?
What about the
member of a NGO who bungles funded money instead of utilizing it for the
required purpose ? Is that not corruption ?
What about the
person who drives without a seat-belt/helmet or over-speeds and tries to bribe
the policeman instead of accepting a ticket ? Is he honest ?
A common-man who
is a honest citizen who is sick and tired of corruption, protests for an
anti-corruption bill without realizing :
How he turns his
head away when his neighbor is hacking the electricity line without using a
valid meter. Just because the neighbor looks after his house when he is away.
How he tries to
bribe a railway official to provide him a seat without having a valid ticket to
travel.
How he skips taking a valid bill while shopping, to evade
the service tax.
How he ignores the fact that his own colleagues are
indulging in corrupt practices while being in either the government or the
private sector.
How he writes an application for a false sickness-leave for
his school going relative just because he skipped school for no reason.
Probably training the kid who may one day himself go on to forge documents as
an official.
How he secretly conducts coaching classes even though it is
illegal for him to do so being a government salaried school/college teacher.
How he bungles up donations collected from the locality in
the name of organizing a religious function.
The above are just a few examples of the types of corruption
a common man takes active part in. And even if I haven't indulged in such acts, I am no less corrupt by being a mute spectator and letting others indulge in such acts just because they are close to me.
But somehow, we seem to be obsessed by linking the word
corruption to everything related to only government offices. We detest at
having to pay a bribe to a stranger in some office, but we are fine when our
own near and dear ones do the same.
I am all for any anti-corruption bill, even if it is
directed only to government related corruption and even if it curbs corruption
by 0.0001%. Anything positive, no matter how little should be appreciated.
But living in a false sense of euphoria that any rule or law
can eradicate corruption or even curb it to a great extent is dangerous.
Corruption is not some dust that can be wiped with the magic
broom of a Bill. It is also not any act. (bribe or otherwise) Corruption is a
part of one’s character. So, even if strict laws are made to check a corrupt
individual, he will always find ways to play by his character.
A rule or a law can be a symptomatic treatment. But just as
in medicine, any symptomatic treatment should be given to suppress the symptoms
while the root cause of the disease is being treated, just relying on a
symptomatic treatment for cure can be dangerous. So, prevention and awareness
of our society through those near to us is the only way to cure the menace of
corruption. And that’s not possible overnight.
As for the government, it can never change till people
continue to vote according to caste, religion and ideologies of political
parties.
So, while I’ll be all for any anti-corruption movement, I,
as a citizen, need to check my own indulgence in any sort of corruption and
also create awareness and prevent those near me to indulge in corruption. I
don’t need to sing, dance, clap or run around with a cap on my head and a tricolor
in my hand in anticipation of a magic cure in the form of a Bill. Even if that
forces me to be labeled as pro-corruption.